Why I Have Never Bought a Self Published Book

I’ve been busy with the revision, but a discussion on a forum I watch has brought up some thoughts.

I have never been able to bring myself to buy a self published book. It’s not because I don’t think that there are good books out there – I’m sure there are. I’m sure there are authors out there who are just too adventurous or unorthodox for traditional publishers to take a chance on them, or some other reason they’ve chosen to self publish rather than go the traditional route.

Self publishing doesn’t mean someone’s a bad writer, but it does mean that there’s been no quality control involved in the publication of the book aside from what is under the author’s control. There’s been no one read over it and decide that yes, this is good enough that it won’t ruin our reputation if we publish it, aside from the author. The reader has no guarantee that the author can string two sentences together. Or for that matter, that it’s not a recipe for chili copied and pasted three hundred times.

Again, a self-pubbed book might be a great book, and I think the odds have been getting a little better, that it will be decent, in light of the fact that more authors are getting frustrated with the traditional publishing world, and self-pubbing rather that waste their time with trying to sell to the traditional publishers. The bigger publishers have become less and less willing to take a chance on something (which is why they ended up going wtf when small press book “The Windup Girl” won the Hugo and the Nebula a few years ago.) But it’s that lack of some minimal quality assurance that is the reason I have yet to purchase a self published book.

Apparently there seems to be some people who think that books that are only available in e-book format, are the same thing as self published books. E-pubbed books may be self published, but not necessarily – there’s lots of small presses out there that are taking advantage of the e-book to get books out there. As far as I’m aware, self-pubbed books are not eligible to even be nominated for the hugo awards, but e-pubbed books are. In my mind, that’s a huge jump, but the main thing is that there’s been an editor who’s agreed to put their reputation on the line by putting their brand on that book.

This is the value of brand, in my opinion. Not just the money put into formatting the book and finding an artist to do cover art, and whatever else goes into a book. It’s the same as I tell my customers at work at the day job (internet tech support) – buy Toshiba or Asus if possible, if you’re looking for a good machine that will last, but whatever you do, dear lord, don’t buy a Dell, you’ll be sending it back for repairs before the warranty is out. What a publisher, even a small press offers me, as a reader, is that guarantee of quality, and if I read one book by them and like it, then there’s the promise of similar quality in other books by the same press. That’s valuable, and as a reader, I’m willing to pay more for that, or, for that matter, willing to pay at all.

See, as a reader, that editor is doing me a service aside from the formatting and commissioning a cover artist, and whatever else is involved in putting out an e-book, and that’s possibly more valuable to me than any of the rest. That editor is going through hundreds of manuscripts and picking out the ones that he or she thinks are worth anyone’s time. My time is valuable to me; with the writing I do, most of the time I spend reading is time I could be spending writing, so I’m loathe to waste it on a book that’s not worth reading. And I don’t want to spend hours and hours reading to find out that the ending sucks. I don’t care if it’s free, if I’ve wasted my time not enjoying a book, I’m pissed. It’s not even about the money, it’s about my time. I’ll do that for another writer, if I’m critiquing their work, but the point of that is to get it ready for publication, I’m not reading for enjoyment then. And sure, I’m willing to pay more for that service – for an editor to read sluch for me so I don’t have to sift through hundreds of self published books and go over reviews hoping that the reviews aren’t just posts from the author’s friends and family patting them on the head.

So that’s my reservations as a reader. Next week I’ll do up a post on my reservations as a writer.


7 responses to “Why I Have Never Bought a Self Published Book

    • Yes and no. You’re certainly right that there are books published traditionally that are utter crap, not even doesn’t-suit-my-tastes, utter loads of total BS. But the proportions of that are small, compared to the number of books in the self published category that are not professional quality. Buying traditionally published books, I’m not running the risk of the book turning out to be a chili recipe copied and pasted three hundred times, or it turning out to be an advertisement trying to suck me into something, or someone’s twelve year old’s nano novel that they haven’t so much as read over for spelling and grammar before sticking it up on amazon. And furthermore, I don’t have to sift through the above to find the ones that are good. A traditionally published book is far more likely to have thoughtful, honest reviews from legitimate reviewers, so that I can check if this is something I’m going to enjoy.

        • I’ve been following a reviewer on livejournal for a few years, and she does both traditionally and self-published books, and the self published ones have not fared well, for the most part. I’m not sure what type of analysis you’re thinking of, but as I’ve explained, I’m not willing to spend hours reading self published books for the sake of proving myself wrong. Which is where brand comes in. If I did happen to find an author, among those thousands of self pubbed authors out there, who was amazing, that only gives me information about that one author. It doesn’t tell me that I can go to this store or this publisher to find more of the same.

          It’s the same with the computer analogy. Sure there will be the odd Toshiba that might be DOA when you pull it out of the box, but the odds of experiencing that with a Dell are astronomically higher. But if you see a computer in a shop and there was no brand name on it at all, you might take it home and find out it’s missing a motherboard.

  1. Pingback: 3 Reasons Why I’m Not Self Publishing | Lindsay Kitson – Dieselpunk Author

  2. Pingback: Wanted: Dieselpunk Recommendations | Lindsay Kitson – Dieselpunk Author

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s